Boating Punch
IngredientsWhat it tastes like
Warm brandy sweetness joins the cane character of rum. A little of each citrus lifts the punch without making it a sour.
Strength: high 4 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
A punch with two spirit bases, aged rum and brandy. Lemon and lime are used in small measures; finely cracked ice gradually lengthens the drink without a soda top-up.
What to buy Use plain white granulated sugar. Fine crystals dissolve more readily in a cold drink.
Substitutions White cane and beet sugar can be measured alike. Crush coarse crystals or stir until the grit has dissolved.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Squeeze a lemon into a cup and strain out the seeds and pulp before measuring. Lemons vary in yield, so measure the juice itself.
Substitutions Use 2 ml of thawed home-frozen lemon juice or unsweetened single-strength lemon juice. Packaged juice has a softer aroma. Lemonade, syrup and undiluted concentrate are different products.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose juicy limes with firm skin. Halve, squeeze into a cup, remove any seeds and measure the juice. Yield per lime varies.
Substitutions Use 1 ml of unsweetened single-strength lime juice or thawed home-frozen juice. Packaged juice has a milder aroma. Lime cordial contains sugar and changes the balance.
Sources
cointreau.comWhat to buy Choose dry grape brandy without added fruit flavour. Oak ageing gives wood and vanilla notes.
Substitutions For a home version, use an equal measure of another aged grape brandy of similar strength. A younger bottle gives more grape aroma and less oak vanilla.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose a plain aged rum with wood, vanilla or caramel aromas. A named island and bottling identify the original style. Colour alone does not establish ageing.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another aged rum of similar strength. A lighter rum gives less oak, while a fuller-bodied one stands out more against the mixers.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Crushed ice means small irregular chips without a puddle of meltwater. Keep it frozen until needed.
Substitutions Wrap regular cubes in a clean sturdy towel and crack with a rolling pin. Measure the chips after crushing, using the unit in the recipe.
Sources
whattocooktoday.comWhat to buy Choose a juicy orange with firm, intact peel. Wash, dry and cut across into wheels or lengthwise into wedges as called for.
Substitutions Use the same amount of blood orange. Squeezing it or leaving the flesh in the drink will tint a pale cocktail.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Buy cocktail cherries packed in syrup. Luxardo uses dark Marasca cherries in thick syrup. Let excess syrup drip off the spoon before serving.
Substitutions Use the same number of drained pitted sour cherries from a fruit preserve. They are softer and usually tarter. Leave the preserving liquid behind.
Garnish Orange half-wheel + Cocktail cherry.
How to make it
Step 1Moisten the sugar
Fine sugar — 8 g; Fresh lemon juice — 2 ml; Fresh lime juice — 1 ml.
Use a spoon to rub fine sugar into the lemon and lime juices in a tall tumbler until it becomes a wet paste.
Use the flat end of a wooden spoon. Press the flesh with a slight twist until juice collects at the bottom. Work in a sturdy container that stays put on the counter.
Report a mistake
Step 2Chill the rum and brandy
Aged grape brandy — 30 ml; Aged rum — 45 ml; Finely cracked serving ice — for serving.
Add fine ice, brandy and rum. Stir up from the bottom until the drink no longer feels gritty.
Steady the vessel with one hand. Sweep the spoon along the wall and across the bottom so liquid at the base circulates with the rest.
Report a mistake
Step 3Dress the punch
Orange half-wheel — 1 piece; Cocktail cherry — 1 piece
Sit the orange and cherry on the ice and tuck a straw against the wall of the glass.
Lift the cherry from its jar with a spoon and let the excess syrup drip back. This keeps the syrup from adding extra sweetness to the measured drink.
Report a mistake
Why this pairing works
Walnuts suit the brandy, while dried fruit echoes the rum sweetness.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Tall 300 ml tumbler
The height is enough for the entire portion, and the drink is conveniently stirred with a long spoon, without overflowing.
A highball has tall, nearly straight sides with room for ice and a long drink.
Another glass you can use A tall glass for water or juice, which will fit all the ingredients of one serving.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Tall 300 ml tumbler.
Orange half-wheel + Cocktail cherry.
Ice: The measured serving ice stays in the glass.
Making your first cocktail?
First, measure the ingredients in separate containers, so you can add them in the order they are in the steps.
The measured serving ice stays in the glass.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Fine sugar
The recipe calls for 8 g. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Fresh lemon juice
Measure 2 ml of lemon juice. It can be squeezed from a fresh lemon.
- Fresh lime juice
The recipe calls for 1 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Aged grape brandy
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Aged rum
Recipe: 45 ml. Suitable also: Coating aged rums.
- Finely cracked serving ice
Use this ingredient for serving.
- Orange half-wheel
The recipe calls for 1 piece. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Cocktail cherry
The recipe calls for 1 piece. Choose the ingredient listed.
The history of the cocktail
Bullock pairs brandy with Santa Cruz rum and measures two citrus juices in dashes.
Read this story in the journalSave recipe
Recipe source
Tom Bullock, The Ideal Bartender (1917) · Boating Punch
Use a spoon to rub fine sugar into the lemon and lime juices in a tall tumbler until it becomes a wet paste. Add fine ice, brandy and rum. Stir up from the bottom until the drink no longer feels gritty. Sit the orange and cherry on the ice and tuck a straw against the wall of the glass.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".
Sources of product clues
Recipe text and instructions · Cocktail Atlas About the editors


Applejack Fix
Fedora
Cohasset Punch
Durkee Cocktail
Brandy Scaffa
Stone Sour