Brooklyn Cocktail
What it tastes like
Sweet vermouth rounds out rye whiskey, with bitterness from Picon and cherry from maraschino.
Strength: high 4 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
The 1908 Brooklyn combines equal parts rye whiskey and vermouth with a dash each of Amer Picon and maraschino. This home version uses sweet red vermouth in place of the historical Bailor bottling.
What's dash? It's a small portion of liquid from a dispenser bottle. Turn it over the glass and take one short stroke down. Two dashes, two strokes. The volume depends on the dispenser.
Garnish The 1908 recipe specifies no garnish.
How to make it
Step 1Chill the glassware
Chill a cocktail glass and put large ice cubes in a mixing glass.
Step 2Pour whiskey and vermouth
Rye whiskey — 45 ml; Sweet red vermouth — 45 ml.
Measure 45 ml each of rye whiskey and sweet red vermouth into the mixing glass.
Step 3Add the two dashes
Amer Picon — 1 dash; Maraschino liqueur — 1 dash.
Add one dash of Amer Picon and one dash of maraschino liqueur.
Step 4Stir over ice
Stir smoothly until the glass feels very cold and the melting ice has slightly diluted the drink.
Step 5Strain and serve
Strain into the chilled glass without ice. Serve ungarnished.
Why this pairing works
The salty accompaniments highlight the spice in the rye without adding sweetness to the vermouth.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Chilled cocktail glass, 120–150 ml
Serve the drink chilled. Strain out the mixing ice and hold the glass by the stem to keep the bowl cold.
A coupe has a wide, shallow bowl with gently curved sides and a slim stem.
Another glass you can use A small wine glass works too. Chill it first and empty out any water before you pour.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Chilled cocktail glass, 120–150 ml.
Ice: Ice in the mixing glass. Serve without cubes.
Making your first cocktail?
The mixing glass is left open, and the barspoon is led along the wall in smooth circular motions.
To strain, pour through a bar strainer. To double-strain, hold a fine sieve over the glass as well.
Ice in the mixing glass. Serve without cubes.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Rye whiskey
Recipe measure: 45 ml. Replacing it with 45 ml bourbon brings sweeter grain notes and softens the peppery finish.
- Sweet red vermouth
The recipe calls for 45 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Amer Picon
The recipe calls for 1 dash. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Maraschino liqueur
The recipe calls for 1 dash. Choose the ingredient listed.
The history of the cocktail
Jack’s Manual calls for equal parts rye whiskey and Bailor vermouth, plus one dash each of Amer Picon and maraschino.
Read onTurn the story
The Brooklyn in a 1908 bar manual
The drink is stirred with ice and strained. The book does not specify how sweet Bailor was.
The atlas uses an Italian-style sweet red vermouth as an accessible home choice. The manual names neither the first bar nor a creator. Amer Picon gives the whiskey and wine a bitter-orange note, and maraschino seasons them with cherry. Another amaro would produce a different version.
Save recipe
Recipe source
Chill a cocktail glass and put large ice cubes in a mixing glass. Measure 45 ml each of rye whiskey and sweet red vermouth into the mixing glass. Add one dash of Amer Picon and one dash of maraschino liqueur. Stir smoothly until the glass feels very cold and the melting ice has slightly diluted the drink. Strain into the chilled glass without ice. Serve ungarnished.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".


Toronto
Manhattan
Adonis
Red Hook
Bijou
Corpse Reviver No. 1