Caribbean Milk Punch
What it tastes like
Vanilla and aged rum come through cold cream, with nutmeg at the surface.
Strength: moderate 3 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
Brennan’s in New Orleans combines cream with two spirits in this cold punch. The vanilla is in the drink itself, while nutmeg perfumes the foam.
Garnish A pinch of ground nutmeg.
How to make it
Step 1Measure the spirits and vanilla syrup
Mount Gay Black Barrel aged rum — 30 ml; Bourbon — 15 ml; Vanilla-bean simple syrup — 30 ml.
Chill the coupe. Measure 30 ml aged rum, 15 ml bourbon and 30 ml vanilla-bean simple syrup into a shaker.
Step 2Add the cream and ice
Heavy cream — 30 ml; Ice cubes for shaking — for shaking.
Add 30 ml cold heavy cream and ice cubes.
Step 3Shake to a light froth
Close the shaker and shake briskly until chilled. Look for a light layer of foam when you open it.
Step 4Strain into the chilled coupe
Strain into the cold coupe, leaving all the ice behind.
Step 5Dust with nutmeg
Ground nutmeg — 1 pinch.
Dust the surface with a pinch of ground nutmeg.
Why this pairing works
Try an unsweetened pecan cracker with the punch. Its crunch cuts through the cream and the nut brings out the vanilla.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Chilled coupe, 150–180 ml
Chill the coupe before serving and hold it by the stem to keep your hand from warming the drink.
A coupe has a wide, shallow bowl with gently curved sides and a slim stem.
Another glass you can use A small wine glass works too. Chill it first and empty out any water before you pour.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Chilled coupe, 150–180 ml.
A pinch of ground nutmeg.
Ice: Ice cubes for shaking. Serve without ice.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
Ice cubes for shaking. Serve without ice.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Mount Gay Black Barrel aged rum
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Bourbon
Recipe measure: 15 ml. Barrel-proof bourbon also works. To make it drier and spicier, substitute 15 ml rye whiskey.
- Vanilla-bean simple syrup
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Heavy cream
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Ground nutmeg
The recipe calls for 1 pinch. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Ice cubes for shaking
Use this ingredient for shaking.
The history of the cocktail
Brennan’s restaurant in New Orleans publishes a milk punch built on aged rum and a smaller pour of bourbon.
Read onTurn the story
Milk punch in New Orleans
The grated nutmeg goes on after straining, so its aroma reaches the drinker before the vanilla and cream.
Save recipe
Recipe source
Brennan’s Restaurant, New Orleans
Chill the coupe. Measure 30 ml aged rum, 15 ml bourbon and 30 ml vanilla-bean simple syrup into a shaker. Add 30 ml cold heavy cream and ice cubes. Close the shaker and shake briskly until chilled. Look for a light layer of foam when you open it. Strain into the cold coupe, leaving all the ice behind. Dust the surface with a pinch of ground nutmeg.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".


Whiskey Sour
Brown Derby
Paper Plane
Bourbon Renewal
Gold Rush
Avenue