Lost Lanai
IngredientsWhat it tastes like
Sweet-tart pineapple and lime come first, followed by cinnamon. The bitters on top give the first sip a distinct spicy edge.
Strength: moderate 3 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
White and gold rum share the base equally. The aromatic bitters go in the shaker, while Peychaud’s is reserved for the top.
What to buy Choose a pourable, sweet cinnamon drinks syrup. To make your own, infuse a cinnamon stick in sugar syrup, remove it and cool.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another cinnamon syrup of similar sweetness. Ground cinnamon alone leaves sediment and supplies no sweetness.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Choose a plain light rum without coconut or spice flavouring. A light-bodied white rum keeps a pale colour and a gentle cane aroma.
Substitutions Use the same volume of another standard-strength light rum. An aged gold rum adds oak vanilla and changes the colour.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose a plain aged rum with wood, vanilla or caramel aromas. A named island and bottling identify the original style. Colour alone does not establish ageing.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another aged rum of similar strength. A lighter rum gives less oak, while a fuller-bodied one stands out more against the mixers.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Juice a ripe, peeled pineapple and strain out any fibres. Look for pineapple as the only ingredient if buying juice.
Substitutions Use 22.5 ml of packaged unsweetened pineapple juice. Pasteurised juice usually tastes a little mellower. Nectar or the syrup from canned fruit adds extra sweetness.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose juicy limes with firm skin. Halve, squeeze into a cup, remove any seeds and measure the juice. Yield per lime varies.
Substitutions Use 15 ml of unsweetened single-strength lime juice or thawed home-frozen juice. Packaged juice has a milder aroma. Lime cordial contains sugar and changes the balance.
Sources
cointreau.comWhat to buy Peychaud’s is a bright red bitters with an anise note. Check whether the recipe specifies drops or dashes: a drop is much smaller than a dash.
Substitutions Dose another New Orleans-style bitters the same way. Standard aromatic bitters will lend warmer spice and less red colour.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose classic aromatic cocktail bitters, a concentrated spice seasoning. A dash is one short flick of a dasher bottle; use a measure when millilitres are specified.
Substitutions With another aromatic bitters brand, work up to the listed measure as dasher tops vary. Orange bitters would replace the warm spice with citrus peel.
Sources
lairdandcompany.comWhat to buy Choose a pineapple with fragrant, firm flesh. Cut out the tough core so the slice is easy to eat.
Substitutions Drain pineapple canned in its own juice and cut the same number of pieces. It is softer, so rest the garnish on the ice or rim.
Sources
barcocktails.ruWhat to buy Buy cocktail cherries packed in syrup. Luxardo uses dark Marasca cherries in thick syrup. Let excess syrup drip off the spoon before serving.
Substitutions Use the same number of drained pitted sour cherries from a fruit preserve. They are softer and usually tarter. Leave the preserving liquid behind.
What to buy For mixing or chilling, add firm cubes just before stirring or shaking. Drain away any pooled meltwater.
Substitutions Use the same amount of bagged drinking ice. Used mixing ice melts faster and adds unwanted water to the next drink.
Sources
diffordsguide.comWhat to buy Crushed ice means small irregular chips without a puddle of meltwater. Keep it frozen until needed.
Substitutions Wrap regular cubes in a clean sturdy towel and crack with a rolling pin. Measure the chips after crushing, using the unit in the recipe.
Sources
whattocooktoday.comWhat's dash? It's a small portion of liquid from a dispenser bottle. Turn it over the glass and take one short stroke down. Two dashes, two strokes. The volume depends on the dispenser.
Garnish Pineapple wedge + Maraschino cherry.
How to make it
Step 1Measure the base
Cinnamon syrup — 15 ml; White rum — 30 ml; Gold rum — 30 ml; Pineapple juice — 22.5 ml; Fresh lime juice — 15 ml; Aromatic bitters — 1 dash.
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Cinnamon syrup (15 ml), White rum (30 ml), Gold rum (30 ml), Pineapple juice (22.5 ml), Fresh lime juice (15 ml), Aromatic bitters (1 dash).
Thick syrup clings to the measure. Hold it upside down over the mixture and scrape it with a teaspoon so the full measured dose goes into the drink. A shaker is a mixing vessel with a tight lid. For a cold, still mixture, a food-safe mixing bottle with a secure screw cap also works.
Report a mistake
Step 2Shake with ice
Ice cubes for shaking — for shaking.
Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10 seconds, until the metal feels cold.
Brace the lid with one hand and the base with the other. Shake back and forth in short, brisk strokes so the ice travels through the liquid. Bring the shaker upright before opening.
Report a mistake
Step 3Strain into the glass
Crushed serving ice — for serving.
Fill the glass with fresh crushed ice. Use a bar strainer to hold back the ice in the shaker and pour the chilled liquid into the serving glass.
Hold the bar strainer firmly at the lip with a finger and tilt the vessel gradually. At home, a small kitchen sieve balanced over the glass will also catch the pieces of ice.
Report a mistake
Step 4Float the bitters
Peychaud’s bitters — 2 dashes.
Scatter two dashes of Peychaud’s over the finished drink. Leave the coloured layer on top so its spice leads the first sip.
A dash is one quick flick from a dasher bottle. Dispense over a spoon first so a stray extra dose of bitters does not go into the drink.
Report a mistake
Step 5Finish the garnish
Pineapple wedge — 1 piece (optional); Maraschino cherry — 1 piece (optional).
For the optional garnish, perch a small pineapple wedge on the rim, then add a drained maraschino cherry.
Lift the cherry from its jar with a spoon and let the excess syrup drip back. This keeps the syrup from adding extra sweetness to the measured drink.
Report a mistake
Why this pairing works
Try grilled shrimp with lime. Their sweetness suits the pineapple, and the seared edges bring out the spice.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Highball glass
The height is enough for the entire portion, and the drink is conveniently stirred with a long spoon, without overflowing.
A highball has tall, nearly straight sides with room for ice and a long drink.
Another glass you can use A tall glass for water or juice, which will fit all the ingredients of one serving.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Highball glass.
Pineapple wedge + Maraschino cherry.
Ice: Fill the serving glass with crushed ice.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
Fill the serving glass with crushed ice.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Cinnamon syrup
Measure 15 ml cinnamon syrup. In Donn’s Mix, this syrup is combined with fresh yellow grapefruit juice.
- White rum
Recipe: 30 ml. Suitable also: White Cuban rum.
- Gold rum
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Pineapple juice
Recipe quantity: 22.5 ml. If using fresh pineapple, press the flesh, strain the juice and measure 22.5 ml.
- Fresh lime juice
The recipe calls for 15 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Peychaud’s bitters
The recipe calls for 2 dashes. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Aromatic bitters
Use 1 dash. Angostura or Peychaud’s bitters also work.
- Pineapple wedge
One piece, if desired. The pantry matcher treats it as optional.
- Maraschino cherry
One piece, if desired. The pantry matcher treats it as optional.
- Ice cubes for shaking
Use this ingredient for shaking.
- Crushed serving ice
Use this ingredient for serving.
The history of the cocktail
Lost Lanai calls for two rums and two bitters.
Read this story in the journalSources
Save recipe
Recipe source
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Cinnamon syrup (15 ml), White rum (30 ml), Gold rum (30 ml), Pineapple juice (22.5 ml), Fresh lime juice (15 ml), Aromatic bitters (1 dash). Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10 seconds, until the metal feels cold. Fill the glass with fresh crushed ice. Use a bar strainer to hold back the ice in the shaker and pour the chilled liquid into the serving glass. Scatter two dashes of Peychaud’s over the finished drink. Leave the coloured layer on top so its spice leads the first sip. For the optional garnish, perch a small pineapple wedge on the rim, then add a drained maraschino cherry.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".
Recipe text and instructions · Cocktail Atlas About the editors


Gilda
Tiger's Claw
Cinnycane
Mary Pickford
Fannie Ward
Piña Colada