Painkiller
What it tastes like
Pineapple outweighs rum in this drink. Coconut cream gives it body, with the scent of nutmeg on top.
Strength: very low 1 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
Pusser’s 2:4:1:1 ratio of rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and sweetened cream of coconut gives 240 ml before dilution. Use sweetened cream of coconut for its body and sweetness, and grate the nutmeg just before serving.
Garnish An orange wedge, a cocktail cherry and freshly grated nutmeg.
How to make it
Step 1Prepare two batches of ice
Fill a shaker with ice cubes. Put fresh ice in a large highball glass for serving.
Step 2Pour the rum and juices
Pusser’s rum — 60 ml; Pineapple juice — 120 ml; Orange juice — 30 ml.
Add the Pusser’s rum, pineapple juice and orange juice to the shaker.
Step 3Add cream of coconut
Sweetened cream of coconut — 30 ml.
Measure the sweetened cream of coconut into the juices and close the shaker securely.
Step 4Shake until cold
Shake vigorously until the tin feels very cold and the coconut cream has blended into the juices.
Step 5Strain over fresh ice
Strain into the prepared highball over the fresh ice.
Step 6Finish the garnish
Orange wedge — 1; Cocktail cherry — 1; Nutmeg — 1 pinch.
Set an orange wedge and cocktail cherry at the rim. Grate a pinch of nutmeg over the top and serve immediately.
Why this pairing works
Chilli heat and lime acidity balance the sweet pineapple and coconut.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Large highball glass, 350–400 ml
The height is enough for the entire portion, and the drink is conveniently stirred with a long spoon, without overflowing.
Highball has high, almost straight walls, and they leave room for a column of ice and a long drink.
Another glass you can use A tall glass for water or juice, which will fit all the ingredients of one serving.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Large highball glass, 350–400 ml.
Cut across the fruit for a citrus wheel, or lengthwise for a wedge. Grate the nutmeg directly over the finished drink. Let the syrup drip off the cherry before placing it in the glass.
Ice: Ice cubes for shaking and fresh cubes in the serving glass.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
To strain, pour through a bar strainer. To double-strain, hold a fine sieve over the glass as well.
Ice cubes for shaking and fresh cubes in the serving glass.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Pusser’s rum
The recipe calls for 60 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Pineapple juice
Recipe quantity: 120 ml. If using fresh pineapple, press the flesh, strain the juice and measure 120 ml.
- Orange juice
Recipe: 30 ml is also suitable: Orange.
- Sweetened cream of coconut
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Orange wedge
The recipe calls for 1. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Cocktail cherry
The recipe calls for 1. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Nutmeg
The recipe calls for 1 pinch. Choose the ingredient listed.
The history of the cocktail
Pusser’s traces the drink to Daphne Henderson at the Soggy Dollar Bar on Jost Van Dyke.
Read onTurn the story
Pineapple, rum and a final dusting of nutmeg
In the company’s account, Charles Tobias later attempted to recreate it, though Henderson did not share her formula. The Pusser’s serve uses four parts pineapple juice to one each of orange juice and sweetened cream of coconut, with rum measured separately.
Shake with ice to blend the cream through the juices. Fresh nutmeg on the finished drink brings spice to the nose before the first sip.
Sources
Save recipe
Recipe source
Fill a shaker with ice cubes. Put fresh ice in a large highball glass for serving. Add the Pusser’s rum, pineapple juice and orange juice to the shaker. Measure the sweetened cream of coconut into the juices and close the shaker securely. Shake vigorously until the tin feels very cold and the coconut cream has blended into the juices. Strain into the prepared highball over the fresh ice. Set an orange wedge and cocktail cherry at the rim. Grate a pinch of nutmeg over the top and serve immediately.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".


Chi-Chi
East India Cocktail
Barracuda
Blue Hawaiian
Pineapple Daiquiri
Matador