Secret Third Option
What it tastes like
Sweet yellow pepper and peach meet tequila and sherry, offset by lime and a salted rim.
Strength: moderate 3 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
Sweet yellow pepper, peach and sherry give this Margarita variation its character. Salt the rim and serve on one large cube.
Garnish Salt on the rim and a lime wheel.
How to make it
Step 1Yellow bell pepper syrup
Juice fresh yellow bell pepper. Blend two parts juice with one part granulated sugar until the grains have dissolved. Use sweet bell pepper for this syrup. Measure ¾ fl oz of finished syrup per cocktail.
Step 2Salt the rim
Salt — for the rim.
Moisten the outside of a double old-fashioned glass rim with cut lime and press it against a saucer of salt. Put one large fresh cube in the glass.
Step 3Measure the five ingredients
Arette blanco tequila — 1 US fl oz; Manzanilla sherry — ½ US fl oz; Giffard Crème de Pêche — ½ US fl oz; Yellow bell pepper syrup — ¾ US fl oz; Fresh lime juice — ¾ US fl oz.
Pour the tequila, sherry and peach liqueur into the shaker. Add equal measures of yellow pepper syrup and fresh lime juice.
Step 4Shake and strain
Shake with ice cubes until the tin feels cold. Strain onto the large cube in the prepared glass, pouring inside the salt rim to leave it intact.
Step 5Finish with lime
Lime — 1 wheel.
Cut a small slit in a lime wheel and slip it onto the rim before serving.
Why this pairing works
Pepper and lime brighten the grilled cheese, and the corn tortilla softens the salt on the rim.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Salt-rimmed double old-fashioned glass.
In a wide low glass, the cubes are conveniently stacked and stirred with a spoon, without splashing the drink.
Rocks are easily recognized by the low silhouette, wide hole and stable base.
Another glass you can use Low stable glass for water with a wide bottom.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Salt-rimmed double old-fashioned glass.
Cut across the fruit for a citrus wheel, or lengthwise for a wedge.
Ice: Ice cubes for shaking and one large fresh cube for serving.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
Ice cubes for shaking and one large fresh cube for serving.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Arette blanco tequila
The recipe calls for 1 US fl oz. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Manzanilla sherry
The recipe calls for ½ US fl oz. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Giffard Crème de Pêche
The recipe calls for ½ US fl oz. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Yellow bell pepper syrup
The recipe calls for ¾ US fl oz. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Fresh lime juice
Measure about 22 ml of lime juice separately. Squeeze a fresh lime and reserve a wedge if the recipe calls for one.
- Salt
Use this ingredient for the rim.
- Lime
The recipe calls for 1 wheel. Choose the ingredient listed.
The history of the cocktail
Kyler Nolan created the drink at Death & Co Denver in 2024.
Read onTurn the story
A third option from the bar archive
An earlier Denver recipe, Lo Wyatt-Zulueta’s Alley Darts, led him back to yellow bell pepper syrup. The title came from a friend spotting a third possibility in a train journey Nolan thought offered only two.
Save recipe
Recipe source
Kyler Nolan, Death & Co Denver, 2024, Death & Co
Juice fresh yellow bell pepper. Blend two parts juice with one part granulated sugar until the grains have dissolved. Use sweet bell pepper for this syrup. Measure ¾ fl oz of finished syrup per cocktail. Moisten the outside of a double old-fashioned glass rim with cut lime and press it against a saucer of salt. Put one large fresh cube in the glass. Pour the tequila, sherry and peach liqueur into the shaker. Add equal measures of yellow pepper syrup and fresh lime juice. Shake with ice cubes until the tin feels cold. Strain onto the large cube in the prepared glass, pouring inside the salt rim to leave it intact. Cut a small slit in a lime wheel and slip it onto the rim before serving.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".


Gin-Gin Mule
Manzanilla Margarita
Andalusian Buck
Pineapple Daiquiri
Bennett Cocktail
Grand Margarita