Split Decision
IngredientsWhat it tastes like
Apple brandy brings fruit to the malt of the Scotch. Vanilla softens both spirits, while Aperol and orange peel give a gentle bitter edge.
Strength: high 4 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
Scotch and apple brandy share the base equally. The published version shakes them with vanilla syrup and a small measure of Aperol.
What to buy Choose a pourable, sweet vanilla drinks syrup. Look for alcohol-free vanilla coffee syrup. Vanilla extract is dosed in drops and supplies little sweetness.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another vanilla syrup of similar sweetness. Homemade syrup infused with a vanilla pod often has a softer aroma.
Sources
monin.usWhat to buy Choose plain Scotch with restrained smoke, such as a mellow blended Scotch. A heavily peated bottling will dominate the mix.
Substitutions For a home version, measure the same amount of a mild blended whisky of similar strength. A different region or style changes the balance of grain, malt and oak.
Sources
dewars.comWhat to buy Look for dry apple spirit such as Calvados. Barrel ageing adds oak; sweet apple liqueur has a different role.
Substitutions Use the same volume of dry apple brandy from another region. A more heavily oaked bottle will contribute more spice and wood.
What to buy Choose bottled Aperol, the bittersweet orange aperitif. Premixed Spritz is already diluted.
Substitutions For a variation, use the same measure of another orange spritz aperitif of similar strength. A more bitter bottle will make the drink taste drier.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Wash and dry an orange. Use a vegetable peeler to remove the coloured outer layer. A flexible strip releases droplets of oil when bent. Thick white pith tastes bitter.
Substitutions Take the same size strip from a tangerine. Its peel is thinner and sweeter-smelling. Juice and dried grated zest cannot spray fresh oil over the glass.
Sources
jeffreymorgenthaler.comWhat to buy For mixing or chilling, add firm cubes just before stirring or shaking. Drain away any pooled meltwater.
Substitutions Use the same amount of bagged drinking ice. Used mixing ice melts faster and adds unwanted water to the next drink.
Sources
diffordsguide.comWhat to buy Choose a solid piece of ice that fits through the rim. It melts more slowly than a handful of small chips.
Substitutions Use several firm standard cubes occupying a similar volume if you lack a large mould. They will dilute the drink faster.
Sources
liberandcompany.comGarnish Orange peel strip.
How to make it
Step 1Measure the base
Madagascar vanilla syrup — 15 ml; Blended Scotch whisky — 30 ml; Apple brandy — 30 ml; Aperol — 7.5 ml.
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Madagascar vanilla syrup (15 ml), Blended Scotch whisky (30 ml), Apple brandy (30 ml), Aperol (7.5 ml).
Thick syrup clings to the measure. Hold it upside down over the mixture and scrape it with a teaspoon so the full measured dose goes into the drink. A shaker is a mixing vessel with a tight lid. For a cold, still mixture, a food-safe mixing bottle with a secure screw cap also works.
Report a mistake
Step 2Shake with ice
Ice cubes for shaking — for shaking.
Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10–15 seconds, until the metal feels cold.
Brace the lid with one hand and the base with the other. Shake back and forth in short, brisk strokes so the ice travels through the liquid. Bring the shaker upright before opening.
Report a mistake
Step 3Strain into the glass
Large ice cube — 1 piece
Place one large fresh ice cube in the glass. Use a bar strainer to hold back the ice in the shaker and pour the chilled liquid into the serving glass.
Hold the bar strainer firmly at the lip with a finger and tilt the vessel gradually. At home, a small kitchen sieve balanced over the glass will also catch the pieces of ice.
Report a mistake
Step 4Finish the garnish
Orange peel strip — 1 piece (optional).
For the optional garnish, express the orange peel over the glass, then slip it into the drink.
A vegetable peeler will lift a thin coloured strip with little white pith. As you bend it above the glass, aim the coloured side at the drink. That is where the fragrant oil sits.
Report a mistake
Why this pairing works
Try unsweetened baked apple and a piece of aged cheese. Apple echoes the brandy, while the cheese balances the vanilla with salt.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Rocks glass
In a wide low glass, the cubes are conveniently stacked and stirred with a spoon, without splashing the drink.
Rocks are easily recognized by the low silhouette, wide hole and stable base.
Another glass you can use Low stable glass for water with a wide bottom.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Rocks glass.
Orange peel strip.
Ice: Place one large ice cube in the serving glass.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
Place one large ice cube in the serving glass.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Madagascar vanilla syrup
The recipe calls for 15 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Blended Scotch whisky
Measure 30 ml. Dewar’s White Label also works. You can substitute 30 ml Irish whiskey for a different grain aroma and barrel character.
- Apple brandy
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Aperol
The recipe calls for 7.5 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Orange peel strip
One piece, if desired. The pantry matcher treats it as optional.
- Ice cubes for shaking
Use this ingredient for shaking.
- Large ice cube
The recipe calls for 1 piece. Choose the ingredient listed.
The history of the cocktail
Split Decision divides its base equally between blended Scotch and apple brandy.
Read this story in the journalSources
Save recipe
Recipe source
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Madagascar vanilla syrup (15 ml), Blended Scotch whisky (30 ml), Apple brandy (30 ml), Aperol (7.5 ml). Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10–15 seconds, until the metal feels cold. Place one large fresh ice cube in the glass. Use a bar strainer to hold back the ice in the shaker and pour the chilled liquid into the serving glass. For the optional garnish, express the orange peel over the glass, then slip it into the drink.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".
Recipe text and instructions · Cocktail Atlas About the editors


Honeymoon
Florianópolis
Brave Companion
London Sour
Penicillin
Chill Passage