Manhattan
Two-room Manhattan

In O.H. Byron's 1884 handbook, Manhattan is two adjacent entries at once. In recipe #1, whiskey and French vermouth go equally; to these are added Angostura and sugar syrup. In recipe #2, French vermouth gives way to Italian, the syrup disappears, and next to the bitters there is a little orange curacao.
This page doesn't name the inventor, it doesn't date the drink, but it does show a lively bar choice: you could order two different Manhattans in the same book, and the sweetness here is changed not only by the amount of sugar, but also by the vermouth itself, so it's more useful when reading an old recipe to look at the exact composition than to assume the name is a guarantee of the only constant formula.
Open the recipe for Manhattan