Old Fashioned
The old manner was flexible.

On the 1930 Savoy Cocktail Book page, Old Fashioned is harvested in a glass, a piece of sugar is rubbed with Angostura, added ice, rye or Canadian whiskey, then stirred, lemon peels and a slice of orange complete the serving, and this is a detailed instruction that you can imagine at the counter without a separate shaker.
Harry Craddock's most interesting line is after the recipe: instead of rye whiskey, he allows you to take brandy, gin or rum. For the reader of that book, "old fashion" was not the name of just one whiskey cocktail. It was the way of assembly, and the combination of a strong drink, sugar and bitters that mattered.
The current IBA card is already more specific: bourbon or rye whiskey, sugar, Angostura and some water. It suggests grinding the sugar, filling the glass with ice cubes and gently stirring. A comparison of two entries shows how the broad antique manner has become a recognizable modern formula.
Open the Old Fashion recipe.