Café Mexicana
IngredientsWhat it tastes like
Coffee liqueur reinforces the cold brew, while amaro and curaçao add herbs and orange peel. Vanilla cream softens the first sips.
Strength: low 2 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
In Café Mexicana cold brew meets tequila, amaro and two liqueurs. The shaking ice goes into the Collins glass beneath a layer of lightly salted cream.
What to buy Choose a pourable, sweet vanilla drinks syrup. Look for alcohol-free vanilla coffee syrup. Vanilla extract is dosed in drops and supplies little sweetness.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another vanilla syrup of similar sweetness. Homemade syrup infused with a vanilla pod often has a softer aroma.
Sources
monin.usWhat to buy Look for reposado tequila made from blue agave. Barrel resting brings soft wood and vanilla notes. Gold colour alone does not establish this style.
Substitutions Use another reposado of similar strength in the same amount. Blanco tequila brings fresher agave and less oak.
Sources
tequileno.comWhat to buy Choose the named dark Italian amaro, a bittersweet herbal liqueur with citrus-peel notes. Cocktail bitters in small dasher bottles are far more concentrated.
Substitutions For a variation, swap Averna and Ramazzotti in the same measure. Both bring a dark, spicy base, but the citrus and finish will differ.
Sources
jeffreymorgenthaler.comWhat to buy Look for dry curaçao, with a noticeable bitter-orange peel flavour. Even a dry curaçao contains sugar.
Substitutions Use the same measure of a drier triple sec for a cleaner orange note. If the original was brandy based, some woody depth will be lost.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Coffee liqueur such as Kahlúa supplies both roasted coffee flavour and sugar. Measure the finished liqueur; espresso plays a different role.
Substitutions Use 7.5 ml of another coffee liqueur. A less sweet cold-brew liqueur emphasises coffee bitterness; pour slowly for layered drinks because density varies.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose unsweetened cold brew. Check whether the bottle is ready to drink or a concentrate.
Substitutions Use the same quantity of homemade strained cold brew. Dilute bottled concentrate to drinking strength as directed first.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy For a cap whisk cold heavy cream to soft waves. Add vanilla and salt separately where specified.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another batch of softly whipped cream. Aerosol cream is often sweetened and wilts sooner.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Grate a pinch from a whole culinary nutmeg on a fine grater. Its fresh aroma is especially noticeable over a warm cup.
Substitutions Use a similarly small pinch of ground nutmeg. Start lightly and add only until a gentle spice aroma is present.
Sources
seedlipdrinks.comWhat to buy For mixing or chilling, add firm cubes just before stirring or shaking. Drain away any pooled meltwater.
Substitutions Use the same amount of bagged drinking ice. Used mixing ice melts faster and adds unwanted water to the next drink.
Sources
diffordsguide.comGarnish Lightly salted vanilla whipped cream + Freshly grated nutmeg.
How to make it
Step 1Measure the base
Madagascar vanilla syrup — 22.5 ml; Reposado tequila — 37.5 ml; Averna amaro — 15 ml; Dry orange curaçao — 7.5 ml; Coffee liqueur — 7.5 ml; Cold-brew coffee — 60 ml.
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Madagascar vanilla syrup (22.5 ml), Reposado tequila (37.5 ml), Averna amaro (15 ml), Dry orange curaçao (7.5 ml), Coffee liqueur (7.5 ml), Cold-brew coffee (60 ml).
Thick syrup clings to the measure. Hold it upside down over the mixture and scrape it with a teaspoon so the full measured dose goes into the drink. A shaker is a mixing vessel with a tight lid. For a cold, still mixture, a food-safe mixing bottle with a secure screw cap also works.
Report a mistake
Step 2Shake with ice
Ice cubes for shaking — for shaking.
Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10 seconds, until the metal feels cold.
Brace the lid with one hand and the base with the other. Shake back and forth in short, brisk strokes so the ice travels through the liquid. Bring the shaker upright before opening.
Report a mistake
Finished drink Step 3Transfer to the glass
Open the shaker and pour the entire contents, including the ice, into the chilled tall glass.
Keep the lip close to the serving glass and tilt gradually. Let the ice slide out with the liquid. Straining the cubes out would change the serve.
Report a mistake
Step 4Finish the garnish
Lightly salted vanilla whipped cream — 1 tbsp (optional); Freshly grated nutmeg — 1 pinch (optional).
For the optional garnish, float a spoonful of lightly salted vanilla whipped cream on the surface, then dust the top with freshly grated nutmeg.
Scoop the foam with a broad spoon and ease it onto the surface. It can then sit on top while the liquid below keeps its own colour.
Report a mistake
Why this pairing works
Toasted pecans complement the roast of the coffee and the nutmeg.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Collins glass
The height is enough for the entire portion, and the drink is conveniently stirred with a long spoon, without overflowing.
A highball has tall, nearly straight sides with room for ice and a long drink.
Another glass you can use A tall glass for water or juice, which will fit all the ingredients of one serving.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Collins glass.
Lightly salted vanilla whipped cream + Freshly grated nutmeg.
Ice: Transfer the shaking ice with the drink into the serving glass.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
Transfer the shaking ice with the drink into the serving glass.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Madagascar vanilla syrup
The recipe calls for 22.5 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Reposado tequila
The recipe calls for 37.5 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Averna amaro
The recipe calls for 15 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Dry orange curaçao
The recipe calls for 7.5 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Coffee liqueur
Measure 7.5 ml. Kahlúa coffee liqueur also works.
- Cold-brew coffee
The recipe calls for 60 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Lightly salted vanilla whipped cream
Use 1 tbsp if desired. This optional ingredient does not affect matching against your cabinet.
- Freshly grated nutmeg
Optional: 1 pinch. This ingredient does not affect pantry matching.
- Ice cubes for shaking
Use this ingredient for shaking.
The history of the cocktail
Liber & Co. describes Café Mexicana as Jarrett Sabatini’s interpretation of Irish coffee.
Read this story in the journalSources
Save recipe
Recipe source
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Madagascar vanilla syrup (22.5 ml), Reposado tequila (37.5 ml), Averna amaro (15 ml), Dry orange curaçao (7.5 ml), Coffee liqueur (7.5 ml), Cold-brew coffee (60 ml). Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10 seconds, until the metal feels cold. Open the shaker and pour the entire contents, including the ice, into the chilled tall glass. For the optional garnish, float a spoonful of lightly salted vanilla whipped cream on the surface, then dust the top with freshly grated nutmeg.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".
Recipe text and instructions · Cocktail Atlas About the editors


Tiger's Claw
Brave Bull
Black Russian
Fig #4
Brave Companion
Split Decision