Horse Thief Cocktail
IngredientsWhat it tastes like
Old Tom opens gently sweet, followed by vermouth herbs and a distinct anise note from the absinthe.
Strength: high 4 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
Old Tom gin, sweet vermouth and green absinthe, stirred over ice and strained into a small cold stem. These three ingredients supply the aroma without a garnish.
What to buy Old Tom is a traditional gin style, often rounder or a little sweeter than London Dry. Look for Old Tom on the label.
Substitutions Use 45 ml of London Dry for a drier, more juniper-led version. Old Toms vary in sweetness, so do not add sugar automatically.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Choose sweet red vermouth labelled rosso or rouge for wine, herbs and sweetness together. Refrigerate after opening.
Substitutions Use the same measure of another sweet red vermouth such as Cinzano Rosso or Martini Rosso. A more bitter bottling will leave a stronger herbal finish.
What to buy Look for absinthe made with wormwood and anise; verte indicates a green style. When rinsing the glass, leave just a film on the walls.
Substitutions Use another absinthe of similar strength and colour in the same measure. Pastis makes a sweeter anise-led variation with less wormwood character.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy For mixing or chilling, add firm cubes just before stirring or shaking. Drain away any pooled meltwater.
Substitutions Use the same amount of bagged drinking ice. Used mixing ice melts faster and adds unwanted water to the next drink.
Sources
diffordsguide.comGarnish No garnish.
How to make it
Step 1Measure the gin and absinthe
Old Tom gin — 45 ml; Sweet red vermouth — 15 ml; Green absinthe — 2 ml.
Pour the Old Tom and sweet vermouth into a mixing glass. Measure the green absinthe separately before adding it.
A stable measuring jug with a spout works as a mixing glass. When the recipe calls for stirring, use a long teaspoon that reaches the bottom.
Report a mistake
Step 2Chill the mixture
Ice cubes for stirring — for stirring.
Add large ice cubes. Run the back of a bar spoon around the wall until the outside is cold.
Rest the back of a long spoon against the inner wall and guide it smoothly around the ice. The cubes should turn together, chilling the liquid without splashing. A long teaspoon can replace a bar spoon for stirring. Use a measuring spoon for a measured dose.
Report a mistake
Step 3Strain into the glass
Hold the ice back with a strainer and pour into a small chilled stem. Serve without a garnish.
Hold the bar strainer firmly at the lip with a finger and tilt the vessel gradually. At home, a small kitchen sieve balanced over the glass will also catch the pieces of ice.
Report a mistake
Why this pairing works
Fresh fennel echoes the anise while lemon lifts the sweet vermouth.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Chilled 120 ml cocktail glass
Serve the chilled drink without ice. The wide bowl shows the surface clearly, and you can hold the glass by its stem.
The straight sides flare out from the stem to form a wide, conical bowl.
Another glass you can use A small chilled coupe or wine glass.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Chilled 120 ml cocktail glass.
No garnish.
Ice: Mixing ice is strained out before serving.
Making your first cocktail?
The mixing glass is left open, and the barspoon is led along the wall in smooth circular motions.
Mixing ice is strained out before serving.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Old Tom gin
Use 45 ml of the listed ingredient. For a drier drink, try 45 ml of London dry gin.
- Sweet red vermouth
Use 15 ml sweet red vermouth labelled rosso. Martini Rosso, Cinzano Rosso and Carpano Antica Formula have different levels of spice and bitterness. Sweet white vermouth can work as a variation at the same 15 ml: expect a paler colour and softer spice. Dry vermouth changes the balance. How vermouth styles differ
- Green absinthe
The recipe calls for 2 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Ice cubes for stirring
Use this ingredient for stirring.
The history of the cocktail
Bullock names an Old Tom gin and Italian vermouth in Horse Thief.
Read this story in the journalSave recipe
Recipe source
Tom Bullock, The Ideal Bartender (1917) · Horse Thief Cocktail
Pour the Old Tom and sweet vermouth into a mixing glass. Measure the green absinthe separately before adding it. Add large ice cubes. Run the back of a bar spoon around the wall until the outside is cold. Hold the ice back with a strainer and pour into a small chilled stem. Serve without a garnish.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".
Recipe text and instructions · Cocktail Atlas About the editors


Duplex Cocktail
Baldy Cocktail
Bloodhound
Cooperstown
Boulevardier
Manhattan