Sweetest Sin
IngredientsWhat it tastes like
Cinnamon and almond soften the bold flavour of the two rums. Lime balances the syrups, and dry curaçao with bitters adds a spiced citrus finish.
Strength: high 4 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
The formula pairs equal measures of overproof Jamaican and Demerara rum. Almond orgeat is used at half the measure of cinnamon syrup.
What to buy Choose a pourable, sweet cinnamon drinks syrup. To make your own, infuse a cinnamon stick in sugar syrup, remove it and cool.
Substitutions Use an equal measure of another cinnamon syrup of similar sweetness. Ground cinnamon alone leaves sediment and supplies no sweetness.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Look for orgeat, a sweet almond syrup for drinks. Shake to recombine any separated nut solids before measuring.
Substitutions Use the same quantity of another orgeat. Clear almond syrup of similar sweetness has less body. Almond extract is too concentrated.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy Look for Jamaican rum marked overproof, which is stronger than standard rum. When white is specified, choose a clear unflavoured bottling.
Substitutions Use the same measure of another Jamaican overproof of similar strength. Regular-strength Jamaican rum makes a lighter drink with a less prominent rum flavour.
Sources
alpenz.comWhat to buy Demerara is a Guyanese rum with a full cane flavour. Check the strength required: standard and overproof Demerara can differ considerably.
Substitutions Use another Guyanese rum of matching style and strength in the same measure. A full-bodied aged rum from another island gives similar weight with different molasses and spice character.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Look for dry curaçao, with a noticeable bitter-orange peel flavour. Even a dry curaçao contains sugar.
Substitutions Use the same measure of a drier triple sec for a cleaner orange note. If the original was brandy based, some woody depth will be lost.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Choose juicy limes with firm skin. Halve, squeeze into a cup, remove any seeds and measure the juice. Yield per lime varies.
Substitutions Use 30 ml of unsweetened single-strength lime juice or thawed home-frozen juice. Packaged juice has a milder aroma. Lime cordial contains sugar and changes the balance.
Sources
cointreau.comWhat to buy Choose tiki bitters, a concentrated blend of warm spices for tropical drinks, in a dasher bottle.
Substitutions The same number of dashes of aromatic bitters keeps the spice accent but may taste more bitter and less cinnamon-led.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Use a whole culinary cinnamon stick for garnish, dry and completely cool. Its toasted scent reaches the nose at the rim.
Substitutions If no toasted stick is ready, use a plain one of the same size. The toasted aroma will be lighter.
Sources
liberandcompany.comWhat to buy Use a tender top sprig of fresh mint with intact leaves. Rinse, blot dry and place near the rim so its scent reaches the nose.
Substitutions Rest a few loose fresh mint leaves on the ice. Dried mint and mint syrup change both the look and the taste. An optional garnish can be left off.
Sources
stgermainliqueur.comWhat to buy Choose a juicy orange with firm, intact peel. Wash, dry and cut across into wheels or lengthwise into wedges as called for.
Substitutions Use the same amount of blood orange. Squeezing it or leaving the flesh in the drink will tint a pale cocktail.
Sources
iba-world.comWhat to buy For mixing or chilling, add firm cubes just before stirring or shaking. Drain away any pooled meltwater.
Substitutions Use the same amount of bagged drinking ice. Used mixing ice melts faster and adds unwanted water to the next drink.
Sources
diffordsguide.comGarnish Cooled toasted cinnamon stick + Mint sprig + Orange wheel.
How to make it
Step 1Measure the base
Cinnamon syrup — 15 ml; Almond orgeat syrup — 7.5 ml; Overproof Jamaican rum — 30 ml; Demerara rum — 30 ml; Dry orange curaçao — 15 ml; Fresh lime juice — 30 ml; Tiki bitters — 1 dropper.
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Cinnamon syrup (15 ml), Almond orgeat syrup (7.5 ml), Overproof Jamaican rum (30 ml), Demerara rum (30 ml), Dry orange curaçao (15 ml), Fresh lime juice (30 ml), Tiki bitters (1 dropper).
Thick syrup clings to the measure. Hold it upside down over the mixture and scrape it with a teaspoon so the full measured dose goes into the drink. A shaker is a mixing vessel with a tight lid. For a cold, still mixture, a food-safe mixing bottle with a secure screw cap also works.
Report a mistake
Step 2Shake with ice
Ice cubes for shaking — for shaking.
Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10 seconds, until the metal feels cold.
Brace the lid with one hand and the base with the other. Shake back and forth in short, brisk strokes so the ice travels through the liquid. Bring the shaker upright before opening.
Report a mistake
Step 3Strain into the glass
Have the chilled serving glass ready. Use a bar strainer to hold back the ice in the shaker and pour the chilled liquid into the serving glass.
Hold the bar strainer firmly at the lip with a finger and tilt the vessel gradually. At home, a small kitchen sieve balanced over the glass will also catch the pieces of ice.
Report a mistake
Step 4Finish the garnish
Cooled toasted cinnamon stick — 1 piece (optional); Mint sprig — 1 piece (optional); Orange wheel — 1 piece (optional).
For the optional garnish, rest a cooled toasted cinnamon stick at the rim, then gently tap a mint sprig between your palms and tuck it beside the rim, then perch a thin orange wheel on the rim.
Use the flat end of a wooden spoon in place of a muddler. A few gentle presses release the aroma. Shredding the leaves creates bitter little scraps.
Report a mistake
Why this pairing works
Try roasted sweet potato with coarse salt. Its sweetness complements the cinnamon and rich rum notes, while the salt brings the lime forward.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Rocks glass
In a wide low glass, the cubes are conveniently stacked and stirred with a spoon, without splashing the drink.
Rocks are easily recognized by the low silhouette, wide hole and stable base.
Another glass you can use Low stable glass for water with a wide bottom.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Rocks glass.
Cooled toasted cinnamon stick + Mint sprig + Orange wheel.
Ice: Chill the mixture with cubes, then serve without ice.
Making your first cocktail?
A cocktail shaker lets you shake the drink with ice. Seal it and keep a hand on each half as you shake.
Chill the mixture with cubes, then serve without ice.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Cinnamon syrup
Measure 15 ml cinnamon syrup. In Donn’s Mix, this syrup is combined with fresh yellow grapefruit juice.
- Almond orgeat syrup
Measure 7.5 ml orgeat, a sweet almond syrup. Amaretto is an almond liqueur.
- Overproof Jamaican rum
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Demerara rum
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Dry orange curaçao
The recipe calls for 15 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Fresh lime juice
The recipe calls for 30 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Tiki bitters
The recipe calls for 1 dropper. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Cooled toasted cinnamon stick
One piece, if desired. The pantry matcher treats it as optional.
- Mint sprig
One piece, if desired. The pantry matcher treats it as optional.
- Orange wheel
One piece, if desired. The pantry matcher treats it as optional.
- Ice cubes for shaking
Use this ingredient for shaking.
The history of the cocktail
The Liber & Co. version of Sweetest Sin combines Demerara rum with overproof Jamaican rum.
Read this story in the journalSources
Save recipe
Recipe source
Measure the following into a shaker for one serving: Cinnamon syrup (15 ml), Almond orgeat syrup (7.5 ml), Overproof Jamaican rum (30 ml), Demerara rum (30 ml), Dry orange curaçao (15 ml), Fresh lime juice (30 ml), Tiki bitters (1 dropper). Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with ice cubes. Seal it and shake firmly for 10 seconds, until the metal feels cold. Have the chilled serving glass ready. Use a bar strainer to hold back the ice in the shaker and pour the chilled liquid into the serving glass. For the optional garnish, rest a cooled toasted cinnamon stick at the rim, then gently tap a mint sprig between your palms and tuck it beside the rim, then perch a thin orange wheel on the rim.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".
Sources of product clues
Recipe text and instructions · Cocktail Atlas About the editors


Gilda
DJ Lisa
Tiger's Claw
Cinnycane
Nouveau Riche
Lost Lanai