Painkiller
Pineapple, rum and a final dusting of nutmeg

Pusser’s traces the Painkiller to Daphne Henderson, owner of the Soggy Dollar Bar on Jost Van Dyke. In the company’s account, Charles Tobias later tried to recreate Henderson’s drink, but she did not share her formula. His version established the familiar four parts pineapple juice to one each of orange juice and sweetened cream of coconut. Rum is measured separately, 60 ml in this serve.
Shake vigorously to distribute the thick cream of coconut through the juice. Grate nutmeg over the drink after pouring so its aroma arrives before the first sip. The bar account and company history explain the Pusser’s version, while Henderson’s exact original recipe remains unconfirmed.
Open the Painkiller recipe