Witch Hunt
What it tastes like
Lemon peel lifts Scotch malt and dry vermouth; Strega leaves a lingering herbal finish.
Strength: high 4 out of 5Based on one serving

Ingredients 1 serving
Recipe note
Scotch and dry vermouth carry a small measure of golden Strega. The liqueur leaves a long herbal finish, while a strip of lemon zest gives the first sip a lift.
Garnish A strip of lemon zest.
How to make it
Step 1Prepare the peel and measure the spirits
Blended Scotch whisky — 45 ml; Dry vermouth — 22.5 ml; Strega herbal liqueur — 15 ml.
Peel a strip of zest from a washed lemon. Measure 45 ml of Scotch, 22.5 ml of dry vermouth and 15 ml of Strega into a mixing glass.
Step 2Add ice to the mixing glass
Ice cubes for stirring — for stirring.
Add ice cubes.
Step 3Stir until cold
Guide the bar spoon around the inside of the glass until the outside feels cold.
Step 4Strain over a large fresh cube
Large ice cube to serve — 1 large cube.
Place one large fresh ice cube in the serving glass. Fit a cocktail strainer over the mixing glass to hold back the used ice, then pour the drink over the fresh cube.
Step 5Express the lemon peel
Lemon zest — 1 strip.
Hold the lemon zest coloured side towards the drink and bend it gently to release the oils. Tuck it beside the ice.
Why this pairing works
Serve with mature cheddar and a thin oat cracker. The richness of the cheese rounds out the Scotch while leaving the herbal finish clear.
The exceptions selected are for the drink. Check the composition of the dish separately.
Glass and serving
Short, wide old-fashioned glass, 200–250 ml
In a wide low glass, the cubes are conveniently stacked and stirred with a spoon, without splashing the drink.
Rocks are easily recognized by the low silhouette, wide hole and stable base.
Another glass you can use Low stable glass for water with a wide bottom.
Tools and ice
Serving glass: Short, wide old-fashioned glass, 200–250 ml.
Cut a thin strip of zest. If the recipe calls for its oils, bend the strip over the glass.
Ice: Mixing ice and one large fresh cube for serving.
Making your first cocktail?
The mixing glass is left open, and the barspoon is led along the wall in smooth circular motions.
Mixing ice and one large fresh cube for serving.
How to Replace Ingredients
The measures in the hints are given for one portion.
- Blended Scotch whisky
The recipe calls for 45 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Dry vermouth
Recipe measure: 22.5 ml. Choose dry or extra dry vermouth, such as Noilly Prat Original Dry. Sweet red vermouth gives a different flavour. A possible substitute is 22.5 ml of dry white wine, which is lighter in alcohol and less herbal. Martini’s guide to vermouth
- Strega herbal liqueur
The recipe calls for 15 ml. Choose the ingredient listed.
- Lemon zest
Recipe: 1 strip. Lemon also works.
- Ice cubes for stirring
Use this ingredient for stirring.
- Large ice cube to serve
The recipe calls for 1 large cube. Choose the ingredient listed.
The history of the cocktail
In the Difford’s Guide recipe, dry vermouth and herbal Strega accompany blended Scotch.
Read onTurn the story
Three ingredients in the Difford’s version
It remains a short drink, stirred in a mixing glass and strained over a separate large cube. Lemon oils are expressed just before serving. This particular specification uses no lemonade.
Sources
Save recipe
Recipe source
Peel a strip of zest from a washed lemon. Measure 45 ml of Scotch, 22.5 ml of dry vermouth and 15 ml of Strega into a mixing glass. Add ice cubes. Guide the bar spoon around the inside of the glass until the outside feels cold. Place one large fresh ice cube in the serving glass. Fit a cocktail strainer over the mixing glass to hold back the used ice, then pour the drink over the fresh cube. Hold the lemon zest coloured side towards the drink and bend it gently to release the oils. Tuck it beside the ice.
Illustration of the presentation created for the "Cocktail Atlas".


Dry Martini
Conference
Gibson
Cardinale
Old Pal
Chrysanthemum